Masthead
Matt
24 Years
Markham, ON
Canada
October 17, 2006
Happy Family Restaurant
02:18 PM

The Site Planning Studio class just turned really uninspiring these past weeks. In the class, we are all given a site in downtown Kitchener, and our task is to rework and develop the site by considering urban design and sense of place theories, while also satisfying the wishes of the client.

Our client is a third-generation Chinese lady. She is an exact replica of Matet Nebres, a reporter on CFTO local news. Her family’s history dates back to the days of the construction of the railroad and the imposition of the Chinese Head Tax. Listening to her story was like watching an episode of ‘???????’ or ‘Stories from Afar’— a Hong Kong documentary series about Chinese people from foreign places around the world who have experienced unique lives.

Her grandparents were apparently the first Chinese families to have settled here in Kitchener. Perhaps systemically, they owned the city’s first Chinese restaurant.

The existing structure of the Chinese restaurant, which has been out of business, is included in our project, as well as two adjacent land parcels. It is quite sad to see the rather shabby conditions they lived in. There is this really rundown shed in the back of the structure that were used to house immigrant cooks. They apparently stayed in makeshift beds in cubical like structures inside the shed.

Anyway, there were lots of ideas in my head, and all seems very neat and interesting until we realized that our client wishes to place a parking facility right smack in the middle of the three land parcels. Say goodbye to nice views.

Sadly, parking makes quite a lot of cash in downtown Kitchener. So parking it is. Now it’s a matter of disguising this bugger as much as possible. But seriously dampens the any sort of grandness in the project.

I’m also very nervous about working in groups. I’m sure all planners are very used to group work by now, but urban design group work feels very different. This is my first urban design group project that I don’t have the company of Shima. It feels so different; I feel inadequate. Team Success has unfortunately been dismantled. Anyways, because of my passively controlling ways, I feel really anxious when I cannot play some leadership role. And because my group consists of third years, who happen to know each other fairly well, I will definitely have to take a backseat for this one. The team seems pretty good, but I hate to feel uncertain about the outcome of our project.

Call me a queeny uptight bitch, but whatever. Someone find me a steering wheel.

Filed under UW Life, published In Waterloo

 

6 Comments
jenn
October 17, 2006 06:30 PM

ha i know how you feel.

October 17, 2006 10:36 PM

I know *exactly* how you feel... try not to have any type of leading role when the people you are working with have no planning/design background what-so-ever... though I have to give them credit, they have exceeded my expectations so far!
Hurry and come to grad school!

Leo
October 17, 2006 11:42 PM

I think when you finish school and do real planning work, you're going to have even more problems with people wanting things like parking lots and you can't do much about it.

Liz
October 18, 2006 01:17 AM

hi matty, are you taking John Lewis' 309 class? I TAed this class last year and it sounds like the same family looking for a restraunt design.
when working w/groups in design one advice i would give is to speak up whenever you have an idea/suggestion... it doesn't matter if you think it's stupid, ppl may actually like it and play off of it... then you become the leader of the group. =) try not to be too pratical because any type of design entitles you to explore (and maybe stretch) the limits of the "box".
i would sooo love to come to your final crits. i miss urban design-ing! =)
GOODLUCK!

Liz
October 18, 2006 01:21 AM

to add to the last part: go crazy with your design! =)
since it's not actually going to be built anyways, at least maybe you can engage them with imagination and humour. and i KNOW you have great ideas! =)

October 18, 2006 12:33 PM

Yeah, apparently this site was used for a previous 309 assignment before. But at the time, there wasn't this parking requirement. There are definitely more visionary things you can do with the site, if we had the ability to implement other things there besides a parking facility.

On another note, surely the client wanting a parking facility demonstrates shows the reality of what might encounter in real-life planning, but at the same time, we also wouldn't be evaluated in real life on how we can present a sense of place to the site either. Sense of place and parking is almost contradictory.

I suppose the professor will maybe overlook some of the theories discussed in class-- given the situation. Who knows.



Post a comment

Comments submissions for this entry are closed.

If you have any feedback regarding this entry, feel free to email me by using this email form. Thanks.